Custom Pies

Flaky, golden, scratch-made pies in classic and seasonal flavors.

From a cozy apple pie to an indulgent peach bourbon caramel, every pie is made from scratch with care. Available in a personal 5-inch size or a full 9-inch pie perfect for sharing.

Our Custom Pies are the only Calico Confections product that are not available to be made gluten-free.

🥧 Pie Flavors

• Apple

• Blueberry

• Caramel Apple

• Door County Cherry

• Peach Bourbon Caramel

• Pecan

• Pumpkin

• Strawberry Rhubarb